RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
A must read for medical professionals treating #Corona from @JAMA_current https://t.co/of4L7z7gF6
When we reach the other side of #COVID19 electronic medical record studies like this will provide useful insights & lessons. In hospitalised patients: 1️⃣1/3 had no fever 2️⃣Hypertension, obesity, and diabetes were common comorbidities https://t.co/y
@GoodSirHamlet I also wonder if there are more hospitalized patients dying. Like, this study fascinated me... 88% of people put on a ventilator in NYC ended up dying anyway: https://t.co/EuBfyOg0Mc
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @KanAugust: 7/ ちなみに、元の論文には、Limitation(限界)というセクションがちゃんとあります。 「この分析を行った日はまだ入院中の患者がいたので、今回の発表にはバイアス(偏り)があるかもしれません。」 https://t.co/L16B8JEj…
RT @KanAugust: 2/ まず、この場合の分母は何でしょうか? この記事の元となる論文にはデータの詳細がありますが、分母を退院者数 + 死者数とすると、確かに 282(死者数) / 320(退院者数 + 死者数) = 88% となります。 https://t.…
RT @robertpdickson: It's irresponsible to publish this kind of misleading mortality data prematurely. The take-away - "88% mortality among…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
Clinical Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among Patients With COVID-19 Hospitalized in the NYC Area https://t.co/y8bUHMWwKw
RT @mattpappas: JAMA isn't taking letters to the editor right now, so my colleagues and I (@medpedshosp @MRothbergMD) wrote a comment inste…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: Link to actual paper fell off: https://t.co/1EAV0jks4p
RT @mattpappas: JAMA isn't taking letters to the editor right now, so my colleagues and I (@medpedshosp @MRothbergMD) wrote a comment inste…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @KanAugust: 2/ まず、この場合の分母は何でしょうか? この記事の元となる論文にはデータの詳細がありますが、分母を退院者数 + 死者数とすると、確かに 282(死者数) / 320(退院者数 + 死者数) = 88% となります。 https://t.…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @EricSecemskyMD: 88% mortality among those intubated? This seems unusually high. I don’t think this mimics our local experience, althou…
@ethanmparker shared this comorbidity study posting in JAMA from data in NY. https://t.co/Q5DmCAtaGB Of interest; Men died at a 2-1 rate over women. Show ventilators may not be helping much. Largest risk factor, hypertension @57%. Next, diabetes @34%. N
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: Link to actual paper fell off: https://t.co/1EAV0jks4p
@ArgaizR @BrendaCrabtreeR @IsaacNunezs22 @SergioRdzRdz @bmarfil @EnriqueSoto8 Ya vi donde estuvo el problema. Supongo que en estos tiempos de publicaciones al vapor con que en el título tengan COVID19, inclusive las publicaciones que han sido “peer reviewe
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @MasuzoeYoichi: 最新の研究では、人工呼吸器を使用のコロナ患者の88.1%が死亡。つまり、人工呼吸器が必要になる前に、アビガンなどの抗ウイルス薬を早期に投与し治療効果を高めねばならないのである。第一線の医者からも、患者の命を救うためにアビガンを使用すべきだと…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
Clinical Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among 5700 Patients With COVID-19 Hospitalized in the NYC Area https://t.co/fLTIfbcvez
RT @CamiloPrietoVal: 6. Acá les dejo el link del estudio para que puedan revisar más a fondo. https://t.co/avj0MLBRW7
There are 3 types of "data" 1) Lies 2) damned Lies 3) Statistics https://t.co/jwEJ5H6v0U
https://t.co/bGcVGlPDSr FYI, important information for the positive people in New York. Great surveys for residents to know the base-body-sick-condition like diabetes and other diseases.That indicates that people are tending to be sick with the COVID-19 wh
RT @deep__wreck: 人工呼吸器を使って8人中7人亡くなっている計算。 「人工呼吸器付けないと死んでしまうけれど、付けてもほぼ助けられない」と捉える必要がある。 ECMOを付ければ魔法の様に治ったり、人工呼吸器付けたらどうにかなる、ではなさそう。この辺り、新聞テ…
RT @JMichaelMcW: Nice clarifying thread
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @MatthewWynia: If you get #COVID19 and need to be put on a vent, it's really bad: "As of April 4, 2020, for patients requiring mechanica…
RT @NickKristof: A very sobering JAMA study of patients treated for Covid-19 in NYC hospitals. Of those placed on ventilators in the study,…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @MatthewWynia: If you get #COVID19 and need to be put on a vent, it's really bad: "As of April 4, 2020, for patients requiring mechanica…
RT @Farzad_MD: 4/ DEATHS ...are delayed This paper got a ton of attention ("87% of all ICU patients die!") but @DrJohnScott nailed it in…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @corrego: mi guru carnívoro, yo le creo.
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @HofstraMed: New in JAMA: Largest US case series, 5700 NY #COVID inpatients at 12 Northwell hospitals, fills gaps in clinical knowledge,…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
If you get #COVID19 and need to be put on a vent, it's really bad: "As of April 4, 2020, for patients requiring mechanical ventilation (n = 1151, 20.2%), 38 (3.3%) were discharged alive, 282 (24.5%) died, and 831 (72.2%) remained in hospital." https://t.co
1/2 @ShekharGupta sir I am a big fan of #CutTheClutter But,in the latest episode you said,"88% mortality among patients put on ventilator” It is factually wrong and misinterpreted. It has important implications In the study published @JAMA_current https:
These slides/graphics might be helpful to further illustrate the letter below. @AAB_IP @JAMA_current
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
JAMA isn't taking letters to the editor right now, so my colleagues and I (@medpedshosp @MRothbergMD) wrote a comment instead. https://t.co/ViGdl9IsjV (2/3)
If you read this paper and thought that 88% mortality seems awfully high, well, it probably is too high. You shouldn't exclude patients from a survival analysis who should be right-censored instead. @medpedshosp @MRothbergMD https://t.co/ViGdl9IsjV (1/3)
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @DrJohnScott: 👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, fo…
RT @CMichaelGibson: Outcomes in 5,700 hospitalized patients in New York. Overall mortality was 21%. 88% of those intubated died. https…
RT @JonPicciniSr: In-hospital mortality of #COVID19 in #NYC is 21%. Wow. To put that in perspective for #cardioTwitter 30-day mortality aft…
mi guru carnívoro, yo le creo.
👏Pleased to see @JAMA_current's correction of recent article re early data on ICU mortality for Covid19 “As of 4/4/20, for pts requiring mechanical ventilation (n=1151, 20%), 38 (3%) were d/c'ed alive, 282 (24%) died, & 831 (72%) remained inhospital.”
@LWestafer @mikejohansenmd @ColinRCooke @DrSamuelBrown @MDqualitysafety I suspect it may have more to do w/ how pts were counted in NY series, with over half still hospitalized and not contributing to outcome. See a great thread here: https://t.co/K1yKxE
RT @hvanspall: #COVID19 case series (n=5700 hospitalized in NYC) 🔹median age 63y, 40%F 🔹HTN, obesity, DM common 🔹At triage, only31% febril…
RT @Farzad_MD: 4/ DEATHS ...are delayed This paper got a ton of attention ("87% of all ICU patients die!") but @DrJohnScott nailed it in…
@DhruvKhullar Agree! Only 30.7% febrile in the @JAMA_current case series of HOSPITALIZED patients https://t.co/u6HFQDg0w0
RT @Farzad_MD: 4/ DEATHS ...are delayed This paper got a ton of attention ("87% of all ICU patients die!") but @DrJohnScott nailed it in…
RT @sonialf: Wow, mortality of 320 patients intubated for #coronavirus in this New York study of 5700 patients was 88%. #covid19 https://t.…
RT @kenmomd: ニューヨークから5700人の症例報告 高血圧、肥満、糖尿病が多い印象。体温の中央値は37.5℃。2.1%は他のウイルスも検出(いわゆる風邪のウイルスが多いが) そのうち退院または死亡した2634例の分析ではICU14.2%、人工呼吸器12.2%、急性腎…
RT @KanAugust: 7/ ちなみに、元の論文には、Limitation(限界)というセクションがちゃんとあります。 「この分析を行った日はまだ入院中の患者がいたので、今回の発表にはバイアス(偏り)があるかもしれません。」 https://t.co/L16B8JEj…
RT @KanAugust: 2/ まず、この場合の分母は何でしょうか? この記事の元となる論文にはデータの詳細がありますが、分母を退院者数 + 死者数とすると、確かに 282(死者数) / 320(退院者数 + 死者数) = 88% となります。 https://t.…
Presenting Characteristics, Comorbidities, & Outcomes Among 5700 Patients Hospitalized With #COVID19 in the New York City Area https://t.co/hgOmnCdhAY #COVID_19 #coronavirus @ISQua @Caitriona_ISQua @Caroline_ISQua @PeterLachman @SimonDonohoe @DrJoshuaT
RT @BuckSexton: Here’s a lot of useful data on covid risk factors and outcomes in patients in NYC https://t.co/AZf8d5cDll
New #COVID19 study in @JAMA_current on 5700 patients in NYC. As of April 4, 2020, for patients requiring mechanical, 3.3% were discharged, 24.5%) died, and 72.2% remain in hospital. Let's hope the survival numbers improve.
The 2nd challenge is that biometric signals are presenting differently in COVID patients. Ex: many people are being told to track temperature. However, in this JAMA manuscript w/ 5700 patients who were hospitalized with COVID-19, only 1/3 had a fever!
RT @KanAugust: 2/ まず、この場合の分母は何でしょうか? この記事の元となる論文にはデータの詳細がありますが、分母を退院者数 + 死者数とすると、確かに 282(死者数) / 320(退院者数 + 死者数) = 88% となります。 https://t.…
RT @kenmomd: ニューヨークから5700人の症例報告 高血圧、肥満、糖尿病が多い印象。体温の中央値は37.5℃。2.1%は他のウイルスも検出(いわゆる風邪のウイルスが多いが) そのうち退院または死亡した2634例の分析ではICU14.2%、人工呼吸器12.2%、急性腎…
RT @KanAugust: 7/ ちなみに、元の論文には、Limitation(限界)というセクションがちゃんとあります。 「この分析を行った日はまだ入院中の患者がいたので、今回の発表にはバイアス(偏り)があるかもしれません。」 https://t.co/L16B8JEj…
RT @GilbertDeray: Première grande cohorte de patients Covid+ hospitalisés à NYC avec une détresse respiratoire. Très grande mortalité; pas…
RT @KanAugust: 2/ まず、この場合の分母は何でしょうか? この記事の元となる論文にはデータの詳細がありますが、分母を退院者数 + 死者数とすると、確かに 282(死者数) / 320(退院者数 + 死者数) = 88% となります。 https://t.…
RT @CamiloPrietoVal: 6. Acá les dejo el link del estudio para que puedan revisar más a fondo. https://t.co/avj0MLBRW7
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
@justin_hart Do you suspect that early/preemptive ventilator use in New York may have been a substantial contributor to the number of deaths? If nearly 90% of patients put on ventilators died, how many did they put on ventilators? https://t.co/fkp75TvrPx
RT @Farzad_MD: 4/ DEATHS ...are delayed This paper got a ton of attention ("87% of all ICU patients die!") but @DrJohnScott nailed it in…
RT @CarnivoreMD: Data gathered from NYC is now mirroring that from China suggesting comorbid conditions/insulin resistance are huge risks f…
4/ DEATHS ...are delayed This paper got a ton of attention ("87% of all ICU patients die!") but @DrJohnScott nailed it in this string: https://t.co/BK31CV9XIB "Among 1,151 pts who were mechanically ventilated, 3% had gone home, 25% had died, & 72% w
RT @ShaliniShahMD: Hot off the press!! Very interesting read-- most common presenting findings and comorbidities in NYC COVID patients. Sam…
RT @CamiloPrietoVal: 6. Acá les dejo el link del estudio para que puedan revisar más a fondo. https://t.co/avj0MLBRW7
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @kenmomd: ニューヨークから5700人の症例報告 高血圧、肥満、糖尿病が多い印象。体温の中央値は37.5℃。2.1%は他のウイルスも検出(いわゆる風邪のウイルスが多いが) そのうち退院または死亡した2634例の分析ではICU14.2%、人工呼吸器12.2%、急性腎…
RT @tomasrdiaz: 18.5% of COVID patients admitted were non English speaking. This is not consistent with demographics of the broader populat…
RT @kenmomd: ニューヨークから5700人の症例報告 高血圧、肥満、糖尿病が多い印象。体温の中央値は37.5℃。2.1%は他のウイルスも検出(いわゆる風邪のウイルスが多いが) そのうち退院または死亡した2634例の分析ではICU14.2%、人工呼吸器12.2%、急性腎…
RT @KanAugust: 7/ ちなみに、元の論文には、Limitation(限界)というセクションがちゃんとあります。 「この分析を行った日はまだ入院中の患者がいたので、今回の発表にはバイアス(偏り)があるかもしれません。」 https://t.co/L16B8JEj…