RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
indeed, this 88% rate is a calculation based on the 2 tails of the distribution (those doing extremely well quickly, and those who pass away very rapidly), but you can't extrapolate on the whole population so easily if the distri is not exactly a perfect b
Interesting observation. Hope that the mortality stays at 25% as Dr. Scott explains. I will have to read the article to comment more
RT @ABsteward: NEW @JAMA_current the largest case series in US NY 5700 pts #COVID19 30.7% were febrile 2% respiratory virus co-infection A…
RT @JacobGudiol: En annan grej från den här studien som är relevant för diskussionen i Sverige Av de över 65 år som fick behandlas med ven…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @EricBillyFR: Mode vulgarisation: aujourd'hui on va parler d'une publication parue dans la revue JAMA et qui s’intéresse aux données cli…
RT @MasuzoeYoichi: 最新の研究では、人工呼吸器を使用のコロナ患者の88.1%が死亡。つまり、人工呼吸器が必要になる前に、アビガンなどの抗ウイルス薬を早期に投与し治療効果を高めねばならないのである。第一線の医者からも、患者の命を救うためにアビガンを使用すべきだと…
@CarlosdelRio7 @HLGatell @EmoryMedicine @emoryhealthcare En la experiencia de Nueva York, la mortalidad fué del 88%... Hay que ser mesurados.con los comentarios... https://t.co/uI5SvCt1S8
"Beware of your denominator." @AlbertsonB2
RT @DrSamGirgis: In New York's largest healthcare system, #COVID19 patients requiring mechanical ventilation had 88% mortality rate... mor…
RT @DrJohnScott: Link to actual paper fell off: https://t.co/1EAV0jks4p
Thread -- I've been correcting this in people's comments, but it's nice to have it laid out so clearly. Tl;dr: 88% of patients WHO EITHER DIED OR WERE DISCHARGED after vents died. Those still in hospital not counted.
RT @BrexitAlex: In the Journal of The American Medical Association: Of 2634 Hospitalised Patients: ❗️57 % had high blood pressure ❗️42 %…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among 5700 Patients Hospitalized With COVID-19 in the New York City. https://t.co/3No5Jz8XvU #covid19 #ny #newyork #comorbidities #pandmic #Statistics
RT @EricSecemskyMD: 88% mortality among those intubated? This seems unusually high. I don’t think this mimics our local experience, althou…
RT @UREssien: Very proud of Dr. Safiya Richardson (@SafiyaMD), a UCSF RISE Scholar, #BlackWomaninMedicine, and first author of the largest…
🤔😱
RT @CureArthritis: Study shows hypertension, obesity, and diabetes most common conditions correlated with severe cases of COVID-19. https:/…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @ABsteward: NEW @JAMA_current the largest case series in US NY 5700 pts #COVID19 30.7% were febrile 2% respiratory virus co-infection A…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @deep__wreck: 人工呼吸器を使って8人中7人亡くなっている計算。 「人工呼吸器付けないと死んでしまうけれど、付けてもほぼ助けられない」と捉える必要がある。 ECMOを付ければ魔法の様に治ったり、人工呼吸器付けたらどうにかなる、ではなさそう。この辺り、新聞テ…
Expérience COVID newyorkaise, mais comment peut-on avoir 21% de mortalité et seulement 14% de prise en charge en réa... ?https://t.co/Hsi1OMckQf
RT @robertpdickson: It's irresponsible to publish this kind of misleading mortality data prematurely. The take-away - "88% mortality among…
RT @EricTopol: Fixed link for @JAMA_current @NorthwellHealth paper https://t.co/13CeozQKlU by @SafiyaMD and colleagues
RT @EthanLSanford: These numbers are frightening. 88.1% mortality for intubated pts...21% overall in hospitalized patients..how can we keep…
RT @meganranney: A few key facts from this case series: 🔸️2% co-infection with another resp virus 🔸️21% mortality of all hospitalized pts…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
@lawhawk @zeynep By all accounts, getting over COVID-19 if you're sick enough to be put on a vent takes a long time; especially the patients admitted towards the end of the period under study had almost no time to recover. Study: https://t.co/XNou2Q9JpQ
RT @BiotechEvol: De 5700 personas hospitalizadas por #COVID19 en USA: - Mortalidad de quienes requirieron ventilación mecánica fue 88.1%. -…
RT @Mahmood88Jo: Clinical Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among Patients With COVID-19 Hospitalized in the NYC Area https://t.…
RT @Greener300: Amazing data .@DanRDimicco .@DavidBCollum .@wsmco .@cate_long
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
@isaacforn Looking at the original study, it doesn't actually say whether Covid patients were more likely to have those conditions than the average person, just that they were the most prevalent conditions. https://t.co/OgBDa7B9jE
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
Question, though. Diagnosed hypertension is extremely common in the US, especially in older age groups. Does the age-adjusted rate of hypertension in the sample equal or exceed the baseline rate for that group as a whole?
@LouiseMensch
RT @CristobMorales: https://t.co/9RUMam6dY3 Presenting Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among 5700 Patients Hospitalized With C…
RT @ebtapper: Who gets admitted with #Covid19 ? 5700 people in NYC in @JAMA_current Common comorbidity: 1️⃣diabetes 2️⃣obesity 3️⃣htn Ov…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
5700 pts hospitalized w/ #COVID19 in #NYC, the most common comorbidities were HTN, #obesity & DM. Among 2634 pts who were discharged or died, 14.2% treated in #ICU, 12.2% received invasive MV & 21% died @SCCM @atscommunity @accpchest @ESICM #medtwi
RT @EricBillyFR: Mode vulgarisation: aujourd'hui on va parler d'une publication parue dans la revue JAMA et qui s’intéresse aux données cli…
Interesting and sad analysis from New York: "Mortality for those who received mechanical ventilation was 88.1%" #Covid_19 #Coronavirus #covid https://t.co/5dud8jUfr2
@lymanstoneky @PublicDiscourse Look at https://t.co/VhiCmjDiLd. Median days (across different ages) until death post-admission was 3.0-5.9. Much less than what you’re assuming.
@JBLascarrou While I agree with your conclusions (both about intubation timing and universal healthcare), these conclusions are a bit misleading. Great thread here from @DrJohnScott https://t.co/K1yKxEueBm
RT @BuckSexton: Here’s a lot of useful data on covid risk factors and outcomes in patients in NYC https://t.co/AZf8d5cDll
Mode vulgarisation: aujourd'hui on va parler d'une publication parue dans la revue JAMA et qui s’intéresse aux données cliniques de plus de 5000 patients de New York: caractéristiques, comorbidités, et évolution de la maladie @LehmannDrC @FZores @Fraslin
RT @EthanLSanford: These numbers are frightening. 88.1% mortality for intubated pts...21% overall in hospitalized patients..how can we keep…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
@CMichaelGibson Perhaps a misleading abstract. See this excellent thread from @DrJohnScott https://t.co/K1yKxEueBm
@thespybrief
Study shows hypertension, obesity, and diabetes most common conditions correlated with severe cases of COVID-19. https://t.co/fOZJ9wDgIG #CureArthritis #COVID19
RT @EdmundTsuiMD: New @JAMA_current study on 5700 hospitalized #COVID19 pts @NorthwellHealth #NewYork. During hospitalization: - 14.2% in…
RT @everydamndayfit: New study showing that 94% of hospitalizations come from people that have at least one underlying condition with hyper…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @miguelrdgzrubio: Anyone taking care of #COVID19 patients in the #ICU should read this thread #SoMe4MV https://t.co/OEUpND2uru
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @EricTopol: Fixed link for @JAMA_current @NorthwellHealth paper https://t.co/13CeozQKlU by @SafiyaMD and colleagues
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @ryoma_tanaka: ニューヨーク市のコロナウィルス患者 人工呼吸器を要した患者の88%が死亡。かなり厳しい状況ですね。 https://t.co/DhLUPfjv1I
RT @shisadoctor: Look at that mortality!!! 35.8% mortality age 70-79...>60% Mortality over age 80!! This is why #geriatrics is terrified a…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @Ichhabra: Here’s the most authentic study @mssnytweet @sonodoc99
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
New study showing that 94% of hospitalizations come from people that have at least one underlying condition with hypertension, obesity, and diabetes being the top 3. https://t.co/8XGYjZbGim https://t.co/nhHR6EQrxo
RT @daltonprice386: [THREAD] Wow. A study published in @JAMA_current today with key numbers about #COVID19 in NYC area, n=5700 and all co…
RT @Ichhabra: Here’s the most authentic study @mssnytweet @sonodoc99 https://t.co/Wewt8VXDFr
RT @UREssien: Very proud of Dr. Safiya Richardson (@SafiyaMD), a UCSF RISE Scholar, #BlackWomaninMedicine, and first author of the largest…
Very low pediatric numbers. But not zero.
A case series published by JAMA shows that high blood pressure, obesity, and diabetes were the most common comorbidities (other patient diagnoses) of hospitalized COVID cases in NY. This evidence links chronic disease with the most severe symptoms. https:/
RT @Mahmood88Jo: Clinical Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among Patients With COVID-19 Hospitalized in the NYC Area https://t.…
Much needed data on 5,7000 its w "severe" #COVID19 (admitted to🏥)in NY in @JAMA_current ▶️6% w cancer similar to prevalence of cancer in US ❓Cancer pts do not seem at higher risk Need data on cancer hx, Rx, and timing & outcomes of COVID19 for risk/
RT @CMichaelGibson: Outcomes in 5,700 hospitalized patients in New York. Overall mortality was 21%. 88% of those intubated died. https…
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @forthman: この数値は、NYCのこちらの報告書の人工呼吸器を装着し、集中治療を受けた患者の死亡率に近いですね。 Mortality rates for those who received mechanical ventilation in the 18-t…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @deep__wreck: 人工呼吸器を使って8人中7人亡くなっている計算。 「人工呼吸器付けないと死んでしまうけれど、付けてもほぼ助けられない」と捉える必要がある。 ECMOを付ければ魔法の様に治ったり、人工呼吸器付けたらどうにかなる、ではなさそう。この辺り、新聞テ…
RT @TomMcGinn4: New @JAMA_current: Largest US case series, 5700 NY #COVID inpatients at 12 Northwell hospitals fills gaps in COVID knowledg…
🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupación medios especializados de #EEUU https://t.co/3OARIjDy0d https://t.co/2ggGbLtGVK
RT @BuckSexton: Here’s a lot of useful data on covid risk factors and outcomes in patients in NYC https://t.co/AZf8d5cDll
RT @shisadoctor: Look at that mortality!!! 35.8% mortality age 70-79...>60% Mortality over age 80!! This is why #geriatrics is terrified a…
This has been the grim reality all along and the reason we never needed that many ventilators. Unfortunately they don’t help. Study showing 88% of patients that got placed in the vent died. https://t.co/rLmqXi4ic4
MUCH better said.
RT @GringaBrazilien: Estudo de 5700 pacientes em 12 Hospitais de New York apresenta dados chocantes de Mortalidade COVID19: ENTUBADOS ✝️76%…
RT @sonialf: Wow, mortality of 320 patients intubated for #coronavirus in this New York study of 5700 patients was 88%. #covid19 https://t.…
この数値は、NYCのこちらの報告書の人工呼吸器を装着し、集中治療を受けた患者の死亡率に近いですね。 Mortality rates for those who received mechanical ventilation in the 18-to-65 and older-than-65 age groups were 76.4% and 97.2%, respectively. https://t.co/xf1SczOizM
Of 5700= 2634 discharged (out of hospital; dead/alive) 3066 still in hospital Of 2634= 2081 went home (79%) 553 died (21%) Of 2634= 2314 weren't intubated (88%) 320 were (12%) Of 553 dead= 271 were not intubated (49%) 282 were (51%) https://t.co/pF5SMQIn7
Clinical Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among Patients With COVID-19 Hospitalized in the NYC Area https://t.co/z4D1b4ZKrW
RT @UREssien: Very proud of Dr. Safiya Richardson (@SafiyaMD), a UCSF RISE Scholar, #BlackWomaninMedicine, and first author of the largest…
RT @meganranney: A few key facts from this case series: 🔸️2% co-infection with another resp virus 🔸️21% mortality of all hospitalized pts…
RT @garyruskin: To save lives, let's end all federal subsidies for advertising of soda, candy and other junk food. New @JAMA_current study…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @JacobGudiol: En annan grej från den här studien som är relevant för diskussionen i Sverige Av de över 65 år som fick behandlas med ven…