@EvanThomas84 Thread worth checking out: https://t.co/S52U9dbT5Z
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @FMouaffak: #COVID19 étude sur 5700 cas hospitalisés Fx de risque dans le désordre : obésité, diabète, hypertension. 84,4% non fumeurs.…
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @FMouaffak: #COVID19 étude sur 5700 cas hospitalisés Fx de risque dans le désordre : obésité, diabète, hypertension. 84,4% non fumeurs.…
RT @FMouaffak: #COVID19 étude sur 5700 cas hospitalisés Fx de risque dans le désordre : obésité, diabète, hypertension. 84,4% non fumeurs.…
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @DrSamuelBrown: How does this get through review? https://t.co/5vvYK4iPun this is not 88% mortality. It may approach 50%, which is scary…
RT @CristobMorales: https://t.co/9RUMam6dY3 Presenting Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among 5700 Patients Hospitalized With C…
RT @DrSamuelBrown: How does this get through review? https://t.co/5vvYK4iPun this is not 88% mortality. It may approach 50%, which is scary…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @CristobMorales: https://t.co/9RUMam6dY3 Presenting Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among 5700 Patients Hospitalized With C…
RT @oxt23: NYの5700人ほど新コロ患者統計でventilator必要になったら平均9割死亡、65以下で約76%死亡、65歳以上で97%死亡って数字見てイタリアで老人見捨てたのもそりゃそうかって感じだな...https://t.co/4zXfOJSa0D
One point does not contradict the other
I think we all need to slow down a little bit
RT @medevidenceblog: Yes, the 88% figure uses a bad denominator. BUT, it is very sobering that over a 35-day period, only 38/1151 (3%) pat…
RT @otapediatrician: これはあくまで保険制度をはじめとして医療体制が異なり、かつ現在最も患者数・死亡数とも世界一のアメリカ単独のデータである。あとアビガンでこの数字が下がるかもまだ不明。 直接日本の状況に当てはめられるデータでは無いことは明らかで、こんなお人…
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @HeatherleeBail1: A case series of characteristics, comorbidities and outcomes on #Covid19 patients in NYC @SCCMPresident @SCCM https://…
Die 88% beziehen sich auf den Beobachtungszeitpunkt und beziehen nur verstorbene und entlassene PatientInnen ein. Das ist missverständlich und würde ich so nicht mehr posten. Aber anders betrachtet: nach nur Ø4,5 Tagen ist ein Viertel aller Beatmeten vers
RT @DavidOstMD: This article https://t.co/eGKXijfXwe published yesterday in @JAMA_current that reports that 88% patients with #COVID19 that…
RT @hvanspall: #COVID19 case series (n=5700 hospitalized in NYC) 🔹median age 63y, 40%F 🔹HTN, obesity, DM common 🔹At triage, only31% febril…
RT @DusetzinaS: Epidemiology is all about the denominator. Here's why. 👇
RT @ScottGottliebMD: Among other notable findings, mortality for those requiring mechanical ventilation in New York was 88.1%. The median l…
RT @CMichaelGibson: Outcomes in 5,700 hospitalized patients in New York. Overall mortality was 21%. 88% of those intubated died. https…
Of 373 ICU patients tracked, 320 were ventilated. 282 of them died. Def not 88% fatality rate bc another 831 ventilated patients were still hospitalized at study end date https://t.co/OToAN9d123 https://t.co/59qnvvVFSs But shows urgency of this debate
RT @CarnivoreMD: Data gathered from NYC is now mirroring that from China suggesting comorbid conditions/insulin resistance are huge risks f…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @garyruskin: To save lives, let's end all federal subsidies for advertising of soda, candy and other junk food. New @JAMA_current study…
RT @SakamotoFumie: ニューヨーク市5700人分のデータ アジア系<10%なのか… https://t.co/HqKzhYaF9S
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
This counts as a public service @DrJohnScott. Thanks.
RT @SakamotoFumie: ニューヨーク市5700人分のデータ アジア系<10%なのか… https://t.co/HqKzhYaF9S
RT @Bob_Wachter: 5/ Second paper: given stakes, key to get messaging right in publications. I was irked by reporting @JAMA_current of study…
RT @Bob_Wachter: 5/ Second paper: given stakes, key to get messaging right in publications. I was irked by reporting @JAMA_current of study…
RT @Bob_Wachter: 5/ Second paper: given stakes, key to get messaging right in publications. I was irked by reporting @JAMA_current of study…
5/ Second paper: given stakes, key to get messaging right in publications. I was irked by reporting @JAMA_current of study of 5700 Covid pts hospitalized Mar 1-Apr 4 at huge @NorthwellHealth system in NYC https://t.co/YhMqPw5J4Y Lots of useful info re: out
RT @DoctorJSpicer: Very interesting findings given that both diabetics and obese patients are known to have primed #neutrophils and high #N…
RT @DoctorJSpicer: Very interesting findings given that both diabetics and obese patients are known to have primed #neutrophils and high #N…
RT @otapediatrician: これはあくまで保険制度をはじめとして医療体制が異なり、かつ現在最も患者数・死亡数とも世界一のアメリカ単独のデータである。あとアビガンでこの数字が下がるかもまだ不明。 直接日本の状況に当てはめられるデータでは無いことは明らかで、こんなお人…
@M_Stone969 @abc13houston That being said, this one has the link, and it’s a pretty solid descriptive study: https://t.co/pNWD9wIVM4
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
うーん。人工呼吸までいくと厳しそうやなあ。まあアメリカのなので単純に比較できないけれども https://t.co/ABeHB5zoaI
@M_Stone969 @abc13houston ??? There is a link to the medical journal literally in the article. https://t.co/mRp23QCzT9
RT @CristobMorales: https://t.co/9RUMam6dY3 Presenting Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among 5700 Patients Hospitalized With C…
RT @AartikSarma: There's been a lot of press coverage of this JAMA paper reporting 88% mortality in ventilated patients (97.5% in age >65!)…
Clinical Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among Patients With COVID-19 Hospitalized in the NYC Area https://t.co/CMmbyAgLbR
Clinical Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among Patients With COVID-19 Hospitalized in the NYC Area https://t.co/enLKbz9vGc
Reading this paper closer. The amount of troponin and BNP elevation noted on patient presentation concerns me for long term myocardial injury consequences. Heart failure cases surge later this year?
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @UREssien: Very proud of Dr. Safiya Richardson (@SafiyaMD), a UCSF RISE Scholar, #BlackWomaninMedicine, and first author of the largest…
RT @gonzaeperez: CARACTERÍSTICAS Y EVENTOS EN 5700 PAC CON #COVID19 EN NYC -63 años, 39.7% ♀️ -56% hipertensos, 41.7% obesos, 33% diabetes…
RT @SaskiaPopescu: And this is why we read the full article and not just the abstract. Thanks for calling out that bad practice @DrJohnScott
RT @FMouaffak: #COVID19 étude sur 5700 cas hospitalisés Fx de risque dans le désordre : obésité, diabète, hypertension. 84,4% non fumeurs.…
@timilhpatel @dhjutsw1 @JAMA_current @UTSWIMchief @UTSWInfDis @InternFrench @DinoKazi @DrJulieTMD @RicardoLaHozMD @TperlTrish You need to be very careful in interpreting mortality rates in this study due to limited f/u time. Most on mechanical ventilation
RT @LuisFernandoGm6: Comorbilidades crónicas más frecuentes en 5700 pacientes hospitalizados por COVID-19 en Estados Unidos: - Hipertens…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @GilbertDeray: Première grande cohorte de patients Covid+ hospitalisés à NYC avec une détresse respiratoire. Très grande mortalité; pas…
RT @AartikSarma: There's been a lot of press coverage of this JAMA paper reporting 88% mortality in ventilated patients (97.5% in age >65!)…
RT @cupallcare: The Co-morbidty of Western Civilization, HTN, Obesity and DM increase risk for poor outcomes. @cupallcare @cuanschutz Clin…
Clinical Characteristics, Comorbidities, and Outcomes Among Patients With COVID-19 Hospitalized in the NYC Area https://t.co/pdkhW5Nd7m
RT @JMichaelMcW: Nice clarifying thread
RT @otapediatrician: これはあくまで保険制度をはじめとして医療体制が異なり、かつ現在最も患者数・死亡数とも世界一のアメリカ単独のデータである。あとアビガンでこの数字が下がるかもまだ不明。 直接日本の状況に当てはめられるデータでは無いことは明らかで、こんなお人…
RT @DrSamuelBrown: How does this get through review? https://t.co/5vvYK4iPun this is not 88% mortality. It may approach 50%, which is scary…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @CarnivoreMD: Data gathered from NYC is now mirroring that from China suggesting comorbid conditions/insulin resistance are huge risks f…
The data is insightful - and disturbing. But with it we can allocate resources in an informed manner. @drjohnwhyte @NIH
Nice clarifying thread
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @otapediatrician: これはあくまで保険制度をはじめとして医療体制が異なり、かつ現在最も患者数・死亡数とも世界一のアメリカ単独のデータである。あとアビガンでこの数字が下がるかもまだ不明。 直接日本の状況に当てはめられるデータでは無いことは明らかで、こんなお人…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @VictorDayan1: 76% and 97% mortality in younger and older than 65 pts who require mechanical ventilation. I am the only one totally shoc…
RT @LuisFernandoGm6: Comorbilidades crónicas más frecuentes en 5700 pacientes hospitalizados por COVID-19 en Estados Unidos: - Hipertens…
RT @PACCMUS: Hey @cnn @NewDay @arianaeunjung @washingtonpost reviewing the JAMA paper of 5700 NYC area patients with COVID-19. https://t.co…
RT @DrJohnScott: THREAD: Lots of alarm over the 🚨88% Mortality🚨among #Covid19 patients on ventilators. The paper *should* say "Among pts on…
RT @hvanspall: #COVID19 case series (n=5700 hospitalized in NYC) 🔹median age 63y, 40%F 🔹HTN, obesity, DM common 🔹At triage, only31% febril…
#COVID19 journal club from the always thoughtful @DrJohnScott 🙏 Lots of data coming out, 👇 why it matters to read the whole paper.
RT @LuisaTriana93: Importante
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @LuisFernandoGm6: Comorbilidades crónicas más frecuentes en 5700 pacientes hospitalizados por COVID-19 en Estados Unidos: - Hipertens…
@AaronRichterman Here's a good thread on it: https://t.co/S8ichUbKq0
Importante
Of the 12% who required ventilation, 88% died (76% of those <65 yo & 97% of elders). Overall mortality was 21%. 1 in 4 hospitalized pts died. Mind blowing. Outcomes Among 5700 Pts Hospitalized W/ #COVID-19 in New York City |Critical Care Medicine
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @otapediatrician: これはあくまで保険制度をはじめとして医療体制が異なり、かつ現在最も患者数・死亡数とも世界一のアメリカ単独のデータである。あとアビガンでこの数字が下がるかもまだ不明。 直接日本の状況に当てはめられるデータでは無いことは明らかで、こんなお人…
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @otapediatrician: これはあくまで保険制度をはじめとして医療体制が異なり、かつ現在最も患者数・死亡数とも世界一のアメリカ単独のデータである。あとアビガンでこの数字が下がるかもまだ不明。 直接日本の状況に当てはめられるデータでは無いことは明らかで、こんなお人…
RT @VictorDayan1: 76% and 97% mortality in younger and older than 65 pts who require mechanical ventilation. I am the only one totally shoc…
RT @AlexBerenson: 1/ Almost 90% of NYC patients put on ventilators died. Remember when @thisismeredith said her hospital was intubating pat…
RT @AaronRichterman: Am I missing something? 88% mortality among intubated patients is meaningless when that is among people who died or we…
RT @ryoma_tanaka: ニューヨーク市のコロナウィルス患者 人工呼吸器を要した患者の88%が死亡。かなり厳しい状況ですね。 https://t.co/DhLUPfjv1I
RT @DrSamuelBrown: How does this get through review? https://t.co/5vvYK4iPun this is not 88% mortality. It may approach 50%, which is scary…
Am I missing something? 88% mortality among intubated patients is meaningless when that is among people who died or were discharged, w a median of 4.5 days at censoring. The only way intubated covid patients arent still hospitalized at d5 is if they die.
RT @hvanspall: #COVID19 case series (n=5700 hospitalized in NYC) 🔹median age 63y, 40%F 🔹HTN, obesity, DM common 🔹At triage, only31% febril…
RT @ryoma_tanaka: ニューヨーク市のコロナウィルス患者 人工呼吸器を要した患者の88%が死亡。かなり厳しい状況ですね。 https://t.co/DhLUPfjv1I
RT @JostoMaffeo: 🛑🛑 HA FALLECIDO EL 88% DE PACIENTES #COVID19 CONECTADOS A RESPIRADOR. 🛑 En #NuevaYork 🤔 😳 Así lo narran con preocupaci…
RT @gonzaeperez: CARACTERÍSTICAS Y EVENTOS EN 5700 PAC CON #COVID19 EN NYC -63 años, 39.7% ♀️ -56% hipertensos, 41.7% obesos, 33% diabetes…
RT @DocWoc71: Conclusion: Among patients who were discharged or died (n = 2634), 14.2% were treated in the intensive care unit, 12.2% recei…